In today’s competitive e-commerce landscape, choosing the right marketplace to sell your products can significantly impact your business’s success.
Two of the most prominent online marketplaces in the United States are Walmart Marketplace and Target Plus. Both platforms offer distinct advantages and cater to different seller needs and customer bases.
This article will comprehensively compare Walmart Marketplace and Target Plus, helping you decide which platform is best suited for your business.
Overview of Walmart Marketplace and Target Plus
Walmart Marketplace
Walmart Marketplace is an online platform where third-party sellers can list and sell their products directly to Walmart’s extensive customer base.
Launched in 2009, it has grown rapidly, offering sellers access to millions of customers who shop at Walmart online and in physical stores.
Key Features and Benefits
- Massive Customer Base: Walmart boasts millions of monthly visitors, providing significant exposure for sellers.
- Trusted Brand: Walmart’s reputation for affordability and reliability can enhance the credibility of third-party sellers.
- Seamless Integration: Sellers can integrate their existing systems with Walmart’s platform for efficient inventory management and order fulfillment.
- Competitive Fees: Walmart Marketplace offers competitive commission rates compared to other major marketplaces.
Target Audience
Walmart Marketplace primarily targets a broad audience, including budget-conscious shoppers, families, and individuals looking for a wide range of products at competitive prices.
Target Plus
Target Plus is Target’s online marketplace, launched in 2019, allowing select third-party sellers to offer their products on Target’s website.
Target Plus is a curated platform, meaning not all sellers can join; it is invitation-only, ensuring a high standard of quality and relevance for Target’s customer base.
Key Features and Benefits
- Curated Selection: By limiting seller access, Target Plus maintains high-quality product offerings, enhancing customer trust and satisfaction.
- Strong Brand Loyalty: Target has a loyal customer base that values style, quality, and innovation, benefiting sellers with high-quality products.
- Seamless Customer Experience: Target Plus integrates smoothly with Target’s overall shopping experience, providing customers with a cohesive and enjoyable shopping journey.
Target Audience
Target Plus attracts a more niche audience, including young professionals, families, and style-conscious shoppers who prioritize quality and design over the lowest price.
Marketplace Features Comparison
Product Listing and Categories
Ease of Listing Products
- Walmart Marketplace: Offers a straightforward product listing process with bulk upload options, making it easier for sellers with large inventories to get started quickly.
- Target Plus: Requires more stringent criteria for product listings due to its curated nature, ensuring only high-quality products are available.
Categories Offered
- Walmart Marketplace: Covers a vast array of categories, from groceries and electronics to apparel and home goods, catering to a wide range of consumer needs.
- Target Plus: Focuses on categories that align with Target’s brand, including home decor, fashion, electronics, and baby products, ensuring a consistent shopping experience for Target customers.
If you’re just starting out and want faster entry into marketplace selling, Walmart is the better option. Its open application process allows more sellers to join, whereas Target+ is invite-only and highly selective.
Fees and Costs
Listing Fees
- Walmart Marketplace: Does not charge listing fees, making it more accessible for new sellers.
- Target Plus: Typically does not charge listing fees either, but the invitation-only nature limits the number of sellers who can join.
Commission Rates
- Walmart Marketplace: Charges commission rates range from 6% to 20%, depending on the product category.
- Target Plus: Also charges commission rates, but these are often competitive and similar to Walmart’s rates.
Other Associated Costs
- Walmart Marketplace: This may include costs for additional services like advertising and fulfillment.
- Target Plus: Similarly, may have additional costs for promotional opportunities and fulfillment services.
Seller Support and Tools
Seller Dashboard and Tools
- Walmart Marketplace: Provides a comprehensive seller dashboard with tools for inventory management, order processing, and performance tracking.
- Target Plus: Offers robust seller tools and support, ensuring high standards of product quality and customer satisfaction.
Customer Support for Sellers
- Walmart Marketplace: Offers dedicated seller support through various channels, including email and phone support.
- Target Plus: Provides personalized support to help sellers navigate the platform and maximize their sales potential.
Fulfillment Options
Fulfillment by Walmart
- Walmart Marketplace: Offers Fulfillment by Walmart (WFS), a service that handles storage, packing, and shipping for sellers, ensuring fast and reliable delivery to customers.
- Target Plus: Does not have a specific fulfillment program like WFS but offers integrated fulfillment services to ensure efficient delivery.
Marketing and Advertising Opportunities
In-Platform Advertising
- Walmart Marketplace: Provides various advertising options, including Sponsored Products, Display Ads, and Walmart Connect, allowing sellers to promote their products effectively.
- Target Plus: Offers promotional opportunities through Target’s marketing channels, including Target Circle and digital ads, to help sellers reach a broader audience.
Promotions and Discounts
- Walmart Marketplace: Allows sellers to create discounts, deals, and promotions to attract customers and boost sales.
- Target Plus: Similarly enables sellers to participate in promotions and discounts to enhance visibility and drive sales.
Seller Requirements and Application Process
Walmart Marketplace
Eligibility Criteria
- Business Requirements: Sellers must have a registered business with valid tax identification.
- Product Requirements: Products must comply with Walmart’s quality standards and policies.
- Performance Standards: Sellers need to meet performance metrics related to order fulfillment, customer service, and product quality.
Application Process
- Apply Online: Complete the online application form, providing details about your business and product offerings.
- Approval: Walmart reviews the application and approves eligible sellers.
- Onboarding: Approved sellers undergo an onboarding process, including account setup and integration.
Target Plus
Eligibility Criteria
- Invitation-Only: Sellers must receive an invitation from Target to join Target Plus.
- Product Requirements: Products must align with Target’s brand and quality standards.
- Performance Standards: Sellers are expected to meet high performance and customer service standards.
Application Process
- Invitation: Receive an invitation from Target Plus based on your product offerings and business reputation.
- Application Submission: Submit detailed information about your business and products for review.
- Approval and Onboarding: Once approved, complete the onboarding process, including product listing and integration.
SWOT Analysis of Each Marketplace
Walmart Marketplace
Strengths
- Large Customer Base: Access to millions of Walmart shoppers.
- Brand Recognition: Leverages Walmart’s trusted brand.
- Competitive Fees: Offers competitive commission rates.
- Fulfillment Services: Provides Fulfillment by Walmart for efficient delivery.
Weaknesses
- High Competition: Many sellers lead to intense competition.
- Strict Policies: Adherence to Walmart’s strict policies and performance standards.
Opportunities
- Expanding Product Range: Opportunity to tap into a wide range of categories.
- Growing E-commerce: Benefit from the continuous growth of online shopping.
Threats
- Market Saturation: Risk of market saturation due to high competition.
- Policy Changes: Potential impact of changes in Walmart’s policies or fees.
Target Plus
Strengths
- Curated Marketplace: High-quality product offerings and less competition.
- Loyal Customer Base: Access to Target’s loyal and style-conscious customers.
- Strong Brand: Leverages Target’s strong brand and customer trust.
Weaknesses
- Invitation-Only: Limited access for new sellers.
- Niche Market: Smaller customer base compared to Walmart.
Opportunities
- Brand Alignment: Opportunity to align with Target’s brand and values.
- Enhanced Visibility: Benefit from Target’s marketing and promotional efforts.
Threats
- Limited Growth: Growth potential may be limited by the invitation-only model.
- High Standards: Risk of being removed if performance standards are not met.
💡 Pro Tip
Walmart typically charges a referral fee between 6% and 20%, depending on the product category. Target doesn’t publicly list their fee structure, as it’s handled on a case-by-case basis for invited sellers.
Pros and Cons for Different Types of Sellers
Small Businesses
Advantages of Walmart Marketplace
- Broad Exposure: Access to a large customer base.
- Competitive Fees: Lower barriers to entry with no listing fees.
- Fulfillment Options: Opportunity to use Fulfillment by Walmart.
Disadvantages of Walmart Marketplace
- High Competition: Intense competition with many sellers.
- Strict Policies: Need to adhere to stringent performance standards.
Advantages of Target Plus
- Curated Marketplace: Less competition with high-quality product offerings.
- Loyal Customer Base: Access to a dedicated and style-conscious audience.
Disadvantages of Target Plus
- Invitation-Only: Limited access for new or smaller sellers.
- Niche Market: Smaller customer base compared to Walmart.
Large Businesses
Advantages of Walmart Marketplace
- Scalability: Ability to reach a vast audience and scale operations.
- Brand Recognition: Leverage Walmart’s trusted brand.
- Advertising Options: Various marketing and promotional opportunities.
Disadvantages of Walmart Marketplace
- Competition: High competition from other large sellers.
- Policy Adherence: Need to comply with Walmart’s strict policies.
Advantages of Target Plus
- Brand Alignment: Opportunity to align with Target’s strong brand.
- Customer Trust: Benefit from Target’s loyal and quality-conscious customers.
Disadvantages of Target Plus
- Selective Entry: Invitation-only model limits entry.
- Market Size: Smaller customer base compared to Walmart.
Niche Product Sellers
Advantages of Walmart Marketplace
- Wide Reach: Access to a diverse customer base interested in various product categories.
- Fulfillment Services: Opportunity to use Fulfillment by Walmart for efficient delivery.
Disadvantages of Walmart Marketplace
- Competition: Competing with a broad range of sellers.
- Policy Compliance: Need to meet strict performance standards.
Advantages of Target Plus
- Curated Selection: Less competition with a focus on high-quality niche products.
- Brand Loyalty: Access to Target’s loyal and discerning customers.
Disadvantages of Target Plus
- Invitation-Only: Limited access for niche sellers without an invitation.
- Smaller Market: Smaller customer base compared to Walmart.
Customer Base and Market Reach
Walmart Marketplace
Demographic Analysis
Walmart Marketplace attracts a diverse demographic, including budget-conscious shoppers, families, and individuals looking for a wide range of products at competitive prices.
The platform appeals to a broad audience due to its extensive product categories and affordable pricing.
Market Reach
Walmart Marketplace has a vast market reach, with millions of monthly visitors both online and in physical stores.
The platform’s extensive network of customers provides sellers with significant exposure and growth opportunities.
Target Plus
Demographic Analysis
Target Plus attracts a more niche audience, including young professionals, families, and style-conscious shoppers who prioritize quality and design.
Target’s customer base is loyal and values the brand’s emphasis on style, quality, and innovation.
Market Reach
Target Plus has a smaller market reach compared to Walmart but benefits from Target’s strong brand loyalty and customer trust.
The platform’s curated approach ensures high-quality product offerings, attracting discerning customers who appreciate quality over quantity.
Final Recommendations and Considerations
Key Factors to Consider
When choosing between Walmart Marketplace and Target Plus, consider the following key factors:
- Product Type: Align your products with the marketplace that best suits their quality and target audience.
- Market Reach: Evaluate the potential customer base and market reach of each platform.
- Competition: Consider the level of competition and how it may impact your sales.
- Fulfillment Options: Assess the available fulfillment services and how they align with your logistics needs.
- Fees and Costs: Compare the fees, commission rates, and additional costs associated with each marketplace.
Situational Recommendations
- For Small Businesses: Walmart Marketplace offers broad exposure and competitive fees, making it a suitable option for small businesses looking to reach a large audience. However, be prepared for high competition and strict performance standards.
- For Large Businesses: Both Walmart Marketplace and Target Plus offer opportunities for large businesses to scale operations. Walmart’s extensive reach and Target’s loyal customer base provide distinct advantages based on your product offerings and brand alignment.
- For Niche Product Sellers: Target Plus may be more suitable for niche product sellers due to its curated selection and loyal customer base. However, gaining access to the platform requires an invitation, which may limit entry.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can anyone sell on Walmart Marketplace?
No, Walmart Marketplace is selective. Sellers must apply and meet specific requirements, such as having a history of marketplace success, competitive pricing, and reliable fulfillment capabilities.
2. Does Target have a marketplace like Walmart?
Yes, Target runs a curated marketplace called Target Plus (Target+). However, it is an invite-only platform, meaning sellers can’t apply directly — they must be invited by Target.
3. Which platform has more traffic for online shoppers — Walmart or Target?
Walmart generally has higher online traffic compared to Target due to its larger product variety, broader customer base, and stronger e-commerce presence.
4. Which marketplace offers better profit margins?
Profit margins vary depending on your product category, pricing strategy, and fulfillment method. Walmart may offer slightly better margins due to its lower commission fees compared to Target+, but this depends on individual business models.
5. Is it easier to get approved as a seller on Walmart or Target?
It’s easier to apply to Walmart, although approval is not guaranteed. Target+ is more exclusive and invite-only, making it more difficult to join.
6. Does Walmart or Target provide fulfillment services like Amazon FBA?
Walmart offers Walmart Fulfillment Services (WFS), similar to Amazon FBA. Target does not currently offer a dedicated fulfillment service for third-party marketplace sellers.
7. Can I sell the same product on both Walmart and Target?
Yes, if you’re approved to sell on both platforms, you can list the same product on each. Keep in mind that Target+ is more restrictive and curated.
8. Which platform is better for brand visibility?
Target may offer stronger brand alignment for premium or niche products due to its curated marketplace approach. Walmart may provide broader visibility due to its higher traffic and wider audience.
9. What kind of support do sellers get on Walmart and Target?
Walmart offers a seller center with resources, customer service, and WFS support. Target+ sellers receive personalized support but may have fewer self-service tools available.
10. How do I decide which platform is right for my business?
Consider your product type, fulfillment capacity, brand positioning, and target audience. If you’re looking for scale and open access, Walmart might be better. If your brand fits Target’s curated experience, it could offer higher perceived value and engagement.
Conclusion
Choosing the right marketplace to sell your products is a critical decision that can significantly impact your business’s success.
Walmart Marketplace and Target Plus each offer unique advantages and cater to different seller needs and customer bases.
Walmart Marketplace provides broad exposure, competitive fees, and extensive fulfillment options, making it an attractive option for a wide range of sellers.
On the other hand, Target Plus offers a curated marketplace with high-quality product offerings and access to Target’s loyal and discerning customers.
By carefully evaluating your business goals, product type, and target audience, you can make an informed decision on which platform is best suited for your business.
Whether you choose Walmart Marketplace or Target Plus, both platforms offer valuable opportunities to grow your online sales and reach new customers.
Take the time to understand the strengths and weaknesses of each marketplace, and align your strategy with the platform that best fits your business needs.
Passionate about blogging and focused on elevating brand visibility through strategic SEO and digital marketing. Always tuned in to the latest trends, I’m dedicated to maximizing engagement and delivering measurable ROI in the dynamic world of digital marketing. Let’s connect and unlock new opportunities together!
